Milwaukee's Trusted Jeweler for Over 57 Years


A Legacy of Jewelry Excellence

PJ Engagement Ring.png__PID:f8cd0d12-73e9-4304-84cd-8b9f60f72112

At Paul's Jewelers, we are dedicated to servicing and repairing jewelry and creating one-of-a-kind masterpieces that go above and beyond expectations. Our in-house team boasts over 170 years of combined experience in the jewelry crafting trade.

We warmly invite you to our showroom to explore some of our many creations and to experience the expertise and world-class service we’re known for.

PJ - Homepage Custom Jewelry_1.jpg__PID:201bbfa5-5a00-46cf-aa37-3b30bb3b2dfe

Create Your Masterpiece

Custom Jewelry Design

Whether you need something special for someone special, or are just looking to treat yourself to a one-of-a-kind piece, our expertise is creating heirloom-grade custom jewelry pieces that will be cherished for years to come.

Contact us for a complimentary consultation, and see how we can help you create your masterpiece.



Customer review - Hand earing Paul's jewelry ring

They helped me with an heirloom ring, gave me some great advice and polished the ring for me! I also left with a necklace made by a local artist. The place is beautiful and the custom pieces are gorgeous.

Tiffany F.

Customer review - Man and Woman hand earing Paul's jewelry ring

Vivian did an excellent job incorporating a loose stone into a beautiful and unique engagement ring. The wedding bands compliment each other and add to the beauty!

Michelle S.

Customer review - Hand earing Paul's jewelry ring

I brought in my already beautiful, heirloom wedding ring to add a piece of our marriage. Vivian knew right away what I was looking for. We placed the order and was told 6 weeks. But we got it back in 3. I absolutely LOVE the addition. It’s still a simple, elegant ring with 3 generations of love.

Kim M.

Customer review - Hand earing Paul's jewelry ring

Vivian is amazing at her craft and customer service is unmatched. They really care about you and making a great ring for you. Will be back!

Aryana B.

Satisfaction Guaranteed


Jeweler assisting customer inside PJs store

At our studio, we have a team of eight goldsmiths with a combined 170 years of experience in repairing and servicing all types of jewelry. Being leaders in the industry, each one of our jewelers performs dozens of jewelry repairs daily for clients in Milwaukee and beyond.

 We understand the sentiment that a cherished piece of jewelry holds, and it is for this reason that every repair project comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

RIng REsizing

Jewelry redesign

jewelry soldering 

gemstonE replacement

Our Promise

With a legacy of serving Milwaukee for over 57 years, we have built a reputation of trust, service, and exceptional craftsmanship.

As your neighborhood jewelers, whether we create your piece or repair it, we promise to treat it as if it were our own. We stand by to give you expert and genuine guidance to help support you on every step of your jewelry journey.

PJ's Team

A Message From Mitch


At Paul’s Jewelers, our mission goes beyond providing exceptional service and jewelry expertise; rather, it’s also about creating lasting relationships with our dear clients.

From seeing our clientele celebrate different milestones over the years, to interacting with them at our community events, we’ve come to understand that jewelry, at its core, is a celebration of personal expression, life, and meaningful moments.

Our greatest pride and joy is the personal connections we make with our fellow neighbors, and seeing how our services and creations become part of their fond memories.

From our family to yours, we stand by as your friends to help you make every moment through jewelry special.

Follow Us


Jeweler smiliting toward the camera
Jeweler smiliting toward the camera
Jeweler inside workplace
Woman holding a dog